Authorship Criteria

Mahkamah: Jurnal Kajian Hukum Islam, published by the Faculty of Sharia, Universitas Islam Negeri Siber Syekh Nurjati Cirebon, is committed to maintaining transparency, accountability, and integrity in scholarly authorship. This policy establishes the criteria for recognizing authors, determining individual contributions, managing authorship changes, and preventing unethical authorship practices.

This policy applies to all manuscripts submitted to the journal.

1. Policy Statement

Authorship represents both academic recognition and responsibility for the integrity of scholarly research. Mahkamah adopts authorship principles consistent with the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE).

All listed authors must have made substantial intellectual contributions and accept responsibility for the originality, accuracy, and integrity of their work.

Authorship must be based on actual scholarly contributions rather than academic rank, institutional affiliation, professional position, or personal relationships.

2. Contribution Requirements

To qualify for authorship, an individual must meet all four criteria:

2.1. Substantial Contribution

Authors must contribute substantially to the conception or design of the research, or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of research data and materials.

For Islamic legal studies, contributions may include analyzing Islamic legal sources, interpreting legislation and judicial decisions, examining classical and contemporary jurisprudence, conducting empirical legal research, or developing theoretical and interdisciplinary legal arguments.

2.2. Manuscript Writing and Critical Revision

Authors must participate in drafting the manuscript or critically revising its important intellectual content.

Proofreading, formatting, language editing, or administrative assistance alone does not qualify an individual for authorship.

2.3. Final Approval

All authors must review and approve the final manuscript and agree to its submission and publication.

2.4. Accountability

All authors must accept responsibility for the integrity of the research and cooperate in resolving questions concerning its accuracy, originality, or reliability.

Individuals who do not meet all four criteria should be acknowledged as contributors rather than listed as authors.

3. Composition of the Authorship Team

Mahkamah welcomes collaboration among researchers from different institutions, countries, academic disciplines, and professional backgrounds.

The journal encourages interdisciplinary research in Islamic family law, Islamic criminal law, Islamic political law, Islamic economic law, Islamic astronomy (falak studies), and related legal disciplines.

Research may employ normative, philosophical, historical, sociological, anthropological, theological, psychological, or economic approaches, provided that the methods are appropriate and clearly explained.

Manuscripts are evaluated based on originality, academic quality, methodological rigor, and relevance to the journal's focus and scope, regardless of the number of authors or their institutional affiliations.

4. Author Identity and Affiliation

All authors must provide accurate identification and affiliation information during submission, including:

  1. Full Name: The author's complete name without academic degrees or professional titles.

  2. Institutional Affiliation: The official institution name, city, and country.

  3. Email Address: A valid email address for academic correspondence.

  4. ORCID iD: Authors are encouraged to provide their ORCID identifier.

  5. Corresponding Author: One author must be designated to communicate with the editorial office.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that all submitted information is accurate and up to date.

5. Author Order

The order of authors must reflect their respective intellectual contributions and be agreed upon before manuscript submission.

The first author is generally the individual who has made the most substantial contribution to the research and manuscript preparation.

The corresponding author must confirm that all co-authors have approved the authorship order.

Authorship order must not be determined by academic rank, institutional authority, or personal relationships.

6. Contributors Who Are Not Authors

Individuals who contribute to the research but do not meet all four authorship criteria should be recognized in the Acknowledgements section.

Such contributions may include administrative assistance, technical support, research funding, language editing, data collection assistance, or institutional facilitation.

Authors must obtain appropriate permission from individuals named in the acknowledgements.

Acknowledgements must not be used to conceal substantial intellectual contributions that qualify an individual for authorship.

7. Prohibited Authorship Practices

Mahkamah prohibits unethical authorship practices, including:

7.1. Gift Authorship

Listing an individual as an author as a gesture of gratitude or personal favor without a qualifying intellectual contribution.

7.2. Guest Authorship

Including a prominent academic or influential individual primarily to increase the manuscript's credibility without a qualifying contribution.

7.3. Ghost Authorship

Intentionally excluding an individual who has made a substantial intellectual contribution and qualifies for authorship.

7.4. Authorship Manipulation

Adding, removing, or rearranging authors for inappropriate purposes, including institutional pressure, personal advantage, or attempts to influence editorial decisions.

Suspected violations will be assessed in accordance with the journal's Publication Ethics policy and may result in manuscript rejection, correction, institutional notification, or other appropriate action.

8. Changes to the List of Authors

Requests to add, remove, or rearrange authors after submission must be formally submitted to the editorial office.

Such requests must include:

  1. A written explanation of the proposed change.

  2. Written agreement from all existing authors.

  3. Written consent from any author being added or removed.

  4. An updated authorship contribution statement, where applicable.

The Editor-in-Chief will evaluate each request and may seek additional documentation.

Authorship changes will not be approved when justification is insufficient or disputes remain unresolved.

Requests made after publication will be assessed according to relevant COPE guidance and may require a formal correction.

9. Authors' Contribution Statement

Mahkamah encourages transparent reporting of individual contributions using the Contributor Roles Taxonomy (CRediT).

Relevant contribution categories include conceptualization, methodology, investigation, formal analysis, data curation, writing—original draft, writing—review and editing, supervision, project administration, and funding acquisition.

An example is provided below:

Authors' Contributions:

Author A: Conceptualization, methodology, legal analysis, and writing—original draft.

Author B: Investigation, data collection, formal analysis, and writing—review and editing.

Author C: Supervision, validation, and critical revision.

All authors must confirm that the contribution statement accurately reflects their respective roles.

Contribution statements do not replace the requirement that every listed author meet the journal's authorship criteria.

10. Editors and Reviewers as Authors

Editors, Editorial Board members, and peer reviewers may submit manuscripts to Mahkamah, provided that the editorial process remains independent and free from conflicts of interest.

The following principles apply:

  1. Their manuscripts must undergo the same editorial screening and peer-review procedures as other submissions.

  2. Editors who are authors or co-authors must not participate in the evaluation or publication decision concerning their manuscripts.

  3. Such manuscripts must be assigned to an independent editor without relevant conflicts of interest.

  4. Reviewers must decline assignments involving personal, professional, financial, or institutional conflicts.

  5. Editorial positions must not provide preferential treatment.

All manuscripts must be evaluated according to their scholarly merit and compliance with the journal's publication policies.

11. Artificial Intelligence and Authorship

Artificial intelligence (AI) tools, including generative AI systems and large language models, cannot be recognized as authors or co-authors of manuscripts submitted to Mahkamah.

AI systems cannot approve manuscripts, accept responsibility for research integrity, or fulfill scholarly accountability requirements.

Authors remain fully responsible for the originality, accuracy, reliability, and integrity of their manuscripts, including content prepared with AI assistance.

The substantive use of AI tools in research or manuscript preparation must be disclosed, including the tools used, their purposes, and the extent of their involvement.

AI-generated references, quotations, legal interpretations, and research findings must be verified against reliable and authentic sources.

The use of AI does not exempt authors from complying with the journal's policies on plagiarism, research misconduct, confidentiality, and publication ethics.