Post-Publication Discussion
Mahkamah: Jurnal Kajian Hukum Islam
1. Policy Statement
Mahkamah: Jurnal Kajian Hukum Islam, published by the Faculty of Sharia, Universitas Islam Negeri Siber Syekh Nurjati Cirebon, is committed to promoting responsible scholarly discussion, academic transparency, and continuous evaluation of published research.
The journal welcomes constructive academic comments, critical responses, and evidence-based discussions concerning published articles in Islamic family law, Islamic criminal law, Islamic political law, Islamic economic law, Islamic astronomy (falak studies), and related interdisciplinary legal studies.
Published research remains open to legitimate academic scrutiny after publication. Scholarly criticism must be supported by verifiable evidence, sound academic reasoning, and respect for professional ethics.
This policy follows the journal's Publication Ethics and relevant guidance issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
2. Eligibility for Participation
Post-publication discussions may be initiated by readers, researchers, authors, academic institutions, legal practitioners, and other parties with legitimate scholarly interests in published research.
Individuals submitting comments must provide their full name, institutional affiliation where applicable, and a valid email address.
Anonymous submissions are not accepted for formal post-publication discussions. However, confidential reports of suspected research misconduct may be handled through the journal's established ethical investigation procedures.
All participants must engage professionally, objectively, and respectfully.
3. Scope of Post-Publication Discussion
Mahkamah welcomes scholarly comments concerning:
-
Research Methodology: Research design, legal research methods, data collection, analytical procedures, and methodological limitations.
-
Interpretation of Findings: Critical evaluation of research findings, legal reasoning, conclusions, and their implications for Islamic legal studies.
-
Theoretical and Legal Perspectives: Alternative interpretations of Islamic legal principles, classical and contemporary jurisprudence, legislation, judicial decisions, fatwas, and relevant scholarly theories.
-
Academic Accuracy: Factual inaccuracies, citation errors, numerical inconsistencies, or other verifiable mistakes.
-
Research Ethics: Ethical compliance, confidentiality, informed consent, and responsible research practices.
-
Research Originality and Integrity: Evidence-based concerns regarding originality, authorship, or research integrity.
The journal does not accept personal attacks, discriminatory statements, defamatory allegations, offensive language, or unsupported accusations.
Serious allegations of research misconduct will be handled under the journal's Publication Ethics, particularly its provisions on Allegation of Research Misconduct.
4. Submission of Post-Publication Comments
Formal post-publication comments must be submitted in writing to the editorial office of Mahkamah: Jurnal Kajian Hukum Islam through the journal's official communication channels.
Submissions should include:
-
Contributor Information: Full name, institutional affiliation where applicable, and valid contact information.
-
Article Identification: Article title, author names, and DOI or permanent article URL.
-
Description of the Issue: A clear explanation of the academic question, criticism, or concern.
-
Supporting Evidence: Relevant academic references, legal sources, research data, or other verifiable evidence.
-
Conflict of Interest Declaration: Disclosure of relevant financial, professional, institutional, or personal interests.
Comments should generally not exceed 1,000 words, excluding references.
Comments submitted through social media or informal communication platforms do not constitute formal submissions under this policy.
Submission does not guarantee publication.
5. Editorial Assessment and Moderation
All submitted comments undergo editorial assessment to ensure academic relevance, ethical compliance, and scholarly quality.
5.1. Acknowledgment of Submission
The editorial office acknowledges receipt of the submitted comment for preliminary assessment.
5.2. Initial Editorial Screening
The editorial team evaluates the relevance, clarity, accuracy, supporting evidence, and professional tone of the comment.
Comments that fail to meet academic or ethical standards may be returned for revision or declined.
5.3. Author Notification and Response
When substantive academic questions arise, the authors of the original article may be invited to provide explanations and supporting evidence.
5.4. Independent Academic Evaluation
When necessary, independent reviewers or subject-matter experts may be consulted to assess methodological, legal, theoretical, or ethical concerns.
5.5. Editorial Decision
The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision regarding acceptance, revision, or rejection.
Editors with relevant conflicts of interest must not participate in the decision-making process.
6. Authors' Rights and Responsibilities
Authors whose published articles become the subject of post-publication discussion have the right to respond to substantive academic criticism.
Authors are expected to:
-
Respond professionally and respectfully to legitimate academic questions.
-
Explain research methods, legal arguments, findings, and conclusions clearly.
-
Provide supporting evidence or scholarly references when necessary.
-
Acknowledge identifiable errors or limitations.
-
Cooperate with the editorial team when clarification, correction, or investigation is required.
Authors must not intimidate, discredit, or retaliate against individuals raising legitimate scholarly concerns.
The journal ensures that authors receive a fair opportunity to respond before substantive editorial conclusions are reached.
7. Publication of Post-Publication Comments
Accepted comments may be published as a Letter to the Editor, scholarly commentary, or another appropriate form of academic discussion supported by the journal.
Responses from the original authors may be published alongside or linked to the accepted comments.
Published discussions should be clearly associated with the original article.
Where technically supported, comments and responses may receive independent bibliographic information, including a DOI.
The publication of a comment does not automatically require modification of the original article. Necessary changes will follow the journal's correction and retraction procedures.
8. Ethical Protection and Confidentiality
Mahkamah: Jurnal Kajian Hukum Islam is committed to protecting the confidentiality, privacy, and rights of individuals and institutions involved in published research.
Post-publication discussions must comply with applicable research ethics and legal requirements concerning personal data protection and confidentiality.
Contributors must not disclose:
-
Personal information identifying research participants without appropriate consent or legal justification.
-
Confidential interview transcripts, recordings, or institutional documents without authorization.
-
Sensitive legal records, financial information, or confidential research materials.
-
Private editorial correspondence or unpublished manuscripts without permission.
-
Information that may expose individuals to foreseeable harm, intimidation, or retaliation.
The editorial office will maintain the confidentiality of unpublished correspondence and submitted materials, subject to disclosures necessary for fair evaluation and applicable legal obligations.
9. Outcomes Affecting Published Articles
Post-publication discussions may identify errors, methodological concerns, or ethical issues requiring editorial action.
9.1. Correction
Corrections may be issued when factual, methodological, citation, or other errors are identified without fundamentally undermining the reliability of the article's principal findings.
Corrections may take the form of an erratum, corrigendum, or addendum.
9.2. Expression of Concern
An expression of concern may be published when serious questions arise regarding an article's reliability or ethical integrity but available evidence remains insufficient for a definitive conclusion.
9.3. Retraction
An article may be retracted when substantial evidence demonstrates that its findings or conclusions are unreliable due to serious errors, plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, or other significant ethical violations.
9.4. Further Editorial Investigation
The editorial team may conduct further evaluation, consult independent experts, or cooperate with relevant academic institutions when additional investigation is necessary.
All correction notices, expressions of concern, and retraction notices will be publicly accessible and linked to the relevant articles.
Where applicable, article metadata and DOI records will be updated.
Retracted articles will generally remain accessible as part of the scholarly record but will be clearly identified as retracted.
10. Editorial Independence and Documentation
All decisions concerning post-publication discussions must be based on scholarly merit, verifiable evidence, academic integrity, and applicable publication ethics.
Editorial decisions must not be influenced by institutional affiliation, nationality, academic seniority, professional position, financial interests, or personal relationships.
Editors with actual or potential conflicts of interest must withdraw from the relevant evaluation and decision-making process.
Mahkamah: Jurnal Kajian Hukum Islam will maintain appropriate records of submitted comments, editorial assessments, author responses, expert evaluations, and editorial decisions.
Such documentation will be managed in accordance with the journal's confidentiality obligations and applicable institutional policies.