Reviewer Guidelines

Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah is committed to maintaining high standards of scholarly quality, academic integrity, and editorial transparency through a rigorous and objective peer review process. Reviewers play an essential role in evaluating the scientific quality, originality, methodological rigor, and scholarly contribution of manuscripts submitted to the journal.

The journal applies a double-blind peer review system, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another. Reviewers are expected to conduct their assessments independently, professionally, constructively, and in accordance with internationally recognized standards of publication ethics.

1. Reviewer Responsibilities

Reviewers are responsible for providing fair, objective, and evidence-based evaluations of manuscripts. They should assess the academic merits of a submission without discrimination based on the authors' nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, religious beliefs, or other personal characteristics. Reviewers should accept an invitation only when they possess sufficient expertise in the subject matter and can complete the evaluation within the specified timeframe. If a reviewer considers a manuscript beyond their area of competence or is unable to meet the deadline, they should promptly inform the editor. Review comments should be clear, constructive, and supported by appropriate academic reasoning. Personal criticism, offensive language, and unsupported judgments are not acceptable.

2. Confidentiality and Conflict of Interest

All manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential scholarly documents. Reviewers must not disclose, distribute, reproduce, or discuss the manuscript or its contents with unauthorized parties. Reviewers must not use unpublished research findings, arguments, data, or other information obtained through the review process for personal research or professional advantage. Any actual or potential conflict of interest arising from personal, professional, institutional, financial, or academic relationships must be disclosed to the editor before accepting a review assignment. Reviewers should decline the invitation when such conflicts could compromise their independence or impartiality. Reviewers must not attempt to identify the authors of manuscripts submitted under the double-blind review system.

3. Manuscript Evaluation Criteria

Reviewers should assess manuscripts according to the following criteria:

a. Relevance to the Journal's Focus and Scope

The manuscript must make a substantive contribution to Sharia economic law, including Islamic commercial law, Islamic financial regulation, Islamic contract law, Sharia governance, dispute resolution, or other areas within the journal's stated scope.

b. Originality and Scholarly Contribution

The manuscript should present original research, a clear research problem, and meaningful contributions to existing scholarly debates. Reviewers should evaluate whether the study offers new legal interpretations, theoretical perspectives, empirical findings, or critical analyses.

c. Theoretical and Conceptual Framework

The manuscript should employ relevant legal theories, Islamic legal concepts, or analytical frameworks. The theoretical approach must be appropriate to the research questions and consistently applied throughout the analysis.

d. Research Methodology

The research design and methods must be clearly explained, appropriate to the research objectives, and systematically implemented. Normative, empirical, socio-legal, and comparative legal studies should demonstrate methodological consistency and sufficient justification for their selected approaches.

e. Quality of Sharia Economic Legal Analysis

Reviewers should pay particular attention to the accuracy, depth, and coherence of the legal analysis. Where relevant, the manuscript should critically engage with Islamic legal sources, fiqh al-mu‘āmalāt, principles of Islamic jurisprudence, fatwas, statutory regulations, judicial decisions, and contemporary legal developments. Legal sources must be interpreted accurately and contextualized appropriately. Manuscripts should move beyond descriptive presentations of Islamic economic concepts and demonstrate substantive legal reasoning and critical analysis.

f. Results and Discussion

The findings and discussion should directly address the research questions, engage critically with relevant literature, and demonstrate a clear relationship between evidence, analysis, and conclusions. Arguments should be logically organized and supported by reliable sources or research data.

g. References and Academic Writing

The manuscript should engage with relevant and credible scholarly literature, including recent research where appropriate. Citations and references must be accurate, consistent, and compliant with the journal's Author Guidelines. The manuscript should demonstrate clarity, coherence, academic integrity, and appropriate scholarly language.

4. Peer Review Procedure

Reviewers receive manuscript evaluation invitations through the journal's Online Journal Systems (OJS) platform. Before accepting an invitation, reviewers should examine the manuscript's title and abstract, assess their subject-matter expertise, consider potential conflicts of interest, and determine whether they can complete the review within the assigned deadline. After accepting the invitation, reviewers should carefully examine the manuscript and submit their evaluations through OJS. Reviewers are encouraged to provide specific comments identifying the manuscript's strengths, weaknesses, and areas requiring improvement. Review reports should distinguish between essential revisions affecting scientific validity and recommendations intended to improve clarity, presentation, or scholarly engagement. Reviewers should submit their evaluations within the deadline specified in the OJS invitation. If additional time is required, reviewers should contact the handling editor as soon as possible.

5. Reviewer Recommendations

After completing the evaluation, reviewers should submit one of the following recommendations, as applicable to the journal's editorial workflow:

a. Accept Submission

The manuscript meets the journal's scholarly standards and is suitable for publication without substantive revision.

b. Revisions Required (Minor Revision)

The manuscript is scientifically sound but requires limited improvements in clarity, structure, argumentation, references, or presentation without substantially altering its research design or principal findings.

c. Resubmit for Review (Major Revision)

The manuscript has potential scholarly value but requires substantial improvements in its theoretical framework, methodology, legal analysis, interpretation of findings, or overall organization before its suitability for publication can be reassessed.

d. Decline Submission

The manuscript has fundamental weaknesses in originality, scholarly contribution, methodological validity, or legal analysis, or does not adequately align with the journal's focus and scope. Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The final editorial decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized handling editor, taking into account the reviewers' assessments and the journal's editorial policies.

6. Publication Ethics and Research Integrity

Reviewers are expected to adhere to recognized principles of publication ethics, including the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers. Reviewers should notify the editor if they identify suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, inappropriate citation practices, research misconduct, fabricated or manipulated data, or substantial overlap with previously published work. Reviewers should not require authors to cite their own publications or particular journals unless such references are genuinely necessary for the scholarly improvement of the manuscript. Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts, unpublished data, or review materials to external artificial intelligence tools or third-party services without explicit authorization from the journal and compliance with applicable confidentiality and data protection requirements. Any authorized use of such tools must not compromise reviewer accountability or the independence of scholarly judgment. Reviewers should maintain professional integrity throughout the review process and respect the confidentiality of editorial correspondence and decisions.

7. Constructive Review and Editorial Communication

A high-quality review report should provide an objective assessment of the manuscript's scholarly contribution and clearly identify areas requiring improvement. Reviewers are encouraged to offer actionable recommendations rather than general criticisms. Comments intended for authors should be constructive, respectful, and focused on improving the manuscript. Any confidential concerns involving ethical misconduct, conflicts of interest, or other sensitive editorial matters should be communicated separately to the editor through the appropriate OJS review fields. Reviewers should cooperate with the editorial team when clarification or additional evaluation is necessary. However, reviewers are not responsible for making final publication decisions.

8. Acknowledgment of Reviewers

Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah recognizes the valuable contributions of peer reviewers in maintaining the academic quality and integrity of the journal. Reviewer contributions may be acknowledged through the journal's official reviewer listing or other appropriate forms of academic recognition, subject to reviewer consent and the preservation of manuscript-level confidentiality. By accepting a review invitation, reviewers agree to follow these guidelines and contribute to a fair, rigorous, and constructive scholarly evaluation process.